Honorable Mention- Star Wars: The Last Jedi.
Many people would probably be shocked that this wasn’t on a top whatever list and others would feel justified in their hatred of the movie that it is absent from the list. However, this film is more than just love it or hate it for me. It’s a complex thing that isn’t shaded by a history with Star Wars and its cannon of characters. Unfortunately I’ve only seen it once and it is something that probably needs to be seen more than that. But, I’ve also only seen Thor and GotG once and they stuck with me more than Star Wars. Even so, I want to dive a little bit into why this movie wasn’t in my top 3.
Star Wars wasn’t a part of my childhood and I actually saw the prequels long before I watched the original trilogy. I’ve seen each movie once each with maybe some repeats for parts of the prequels. But, since I had seen these movies “in order”, they don’t feel like prequels, though I had known Anakin was going to turn eventually, they felt just like the first movies in a series. I also didn’t retain information from the movie- I only know names like Naboo because I’ve been on Star Tours often with Star Wars nerds. I barely understood what was going on with the Senate and the Emperor. I don’t understand fully why the Jedis are mainly gone or why they were gone (before viewing TLJ and having some deeper discussions and reading a lot of write ups). I didn’t get how the Jedi and the Sith were so divided and how strict the Jedi had become in their ideology about love and feelings- maybe I just didn’t pay enough attention, maybe it never really sank in, maybe this is how someone who just watches the movies and doesn’t absorb the literature around the topic can still enjoy the product without having a huge emotional investment in the results.
With all that being said- I didn’t get the reaction to TLJ from the fans. I didn’t realize it “turned the franchise on its head” because that history wasn’t there for me. I thought the characters were great- many of them underwent big development since TFA and I enjoyed where they were going. I thought the introduction of the new characters was great- and I’m loving the diversity we are getting with the cast. Some of the visuals were beyond breathtaking and the comedy was fun. I thought the movie fell perfectly in line with what I’m used to in many sci-fi/fantasy books I’ve read and movies I’ve seen. I’m happy that Rey wasn’t revealed to be particularly special, though I would have liked some type of connection- as is typical in many fantasy series. I thought there were parts that were a little lengthy and I thought other parts were unexplained or too short. Overall, I look forward to watching it again, but it didn’t strike me the way the other films in my top list had. I do think that the lack of a “history” with the franchise and characters does take away some of the hard emotional response from me and I was able to view this as just another movie. While I don’t mind this, I find many fans rely on this change in cannon to fuel their arguments and this can be frustrating. Tell me more about the character development-for both the new and old characters; talk to me about the visual style; and speak to the pace of the film. And understand that, while I don’t see this movie the same as you, doesn’t invalidate my feelings toward the film.